We have seen three rounds so far, and Vista clearly won two of them (Security, Manageability) with knock outs and lost the last one (Reliability) on points, mostly because the old champion XP just picked up lots of experience in its countless fights over the last 7 years. Let’s see if the old man can also outlast the young challenger when it comes to elasticity and smoothness. We are talking now about usability.

This is my summary of referee Kennedy’s judgment of the fourth round:

start_searchAero’s changes are only superficial. Many settings were moved to other places which makes it difficult for XP veterans to find their way on Vista. Most modifications of the user interface were just made for the sake of change and didn’t improve usability. Some modifications are even a change for the worse. The “up a level button” in Explorer is missing, the Search field shows up much too often, and the backup tool doesn’t provide enough feedback about the success of backups.

Even though Kennedy says that “the jury's still out on whether [usability is] better,” it has become quite obvious that he really dislikes Vista’s user interface. The problem certainly is that it is quite difficult to find objective measures with regard to usability. The quality of user interface is to a large extent a matter of taste. However, I find the examples given by Kennedy to be quite revealing. Let me address just one of them.

explorer He misses the “up a level” button in Explorer and the new “foreign-looking” address bar doesn’t compensate for this big loss. This is very hard to understand for me because I think that this new feature of Vista’s Explorer is indeed an improvement. You can still navigate to a higher level with just a mouse click. All you have to do is click on the name of the corresponding folder in the address bar. The good thing about this change is that you can also reach all other upper levels this way with only a mouse click. If you often use the Explorer, then this will certainly speed up your work significantly.

I have said that Kennedy’s judgment is revealing. I think he gave away his secret when he let himself be carried away by using the term “foreign-looking.” Isn’t any change foreign-looking? I mean, if it looks familiar it is not really a change worth mentioning, is it? So, could it be that he belongs to those who just dislike any kind of change? Another explanation is that the he didn’t really spend much time with Vista to explore the new capabilities of its user interface. The other examples he gives lead me to assume the latter.

I have met quite a few Vista opponents who have complained about the many changes in the user interface, which in their opinion seems to make no sense. But every time I pumped them for more details, it became clear that they simply didn’t want to invest time to find out how they could benefit from the changes. The best way to learn to value the new user interface is to logon to an XP machine after working with Vista for a couple of months. Only then will you realize how clumsy XP’s old-fashioned interface really is.

Subscribe to 4sysops newsletter!

In my view, the new Start Search prompt which lets you launch applications quickly and easily is reason enough to let Vista win this round. Yeah, I know, there are numerous free extensions that offer the same feature for Windows XP. And yes, there are free third-party desktop search tools, free Explorer replacements, and so on. But let’s face it; you don’t have the time to deploy them all in your network, do you?

  1. nev 15 years ago

    After over a year with Vista…

    Here’s some “I can’t stand” Items”
    -“MOVE TO” function in explorer missing.
    -Folder keeps forgetting settings. (just bc there’s a image file in the folder doesn’t mean I want it all in thumbnails!)
    -Network Connections is a labyrinth. (used to be one click to network connections.. now making a vpn is takes like guessing game of clicks).
    -Start Search prompt is buggy.. won’t launch some apps(word/excel 07!)… so I have to manually have to go in.
    -slooooowwww… (I have an Mtron 16GB SSD.. that flies with XP on it!)

    The only thing I would miss is the full system backup (that only goes for those with Ult/Business/Ent. versions).

    PS, Server 2008 as a workstation runs as fast as XP… If I had to reinstall, it will be Server 2008.

  2. ochiru 15 years ago

    Start search prompt is indeed good enough in itself but try that with Start++ and you will never want go back to classic start menu.


    “PS, Server 2008 as a workstation runs as fast as XP… If I had to reinstall, it will be Server 2008.”

    I think there was MS employee (forgot who) who said he uses Server 2008 as his primary OS and everything else is on Virtual Machines. That would be a really good option for my work laptop.

  3. Nev, hmm what do you mean with “move to function”. You can move files in Vista the same way you did in XP. It is funny somehow that you complain that Explorer keeps forgetting your folder settings. I often had this problem under XP, but never under Vista. I also didn’t like the new Network Configuration Center in the beginning, but I now like it better than under XP. The fastest way I know to change the network settings is to right click on Network in the Start Menu and then navigate to Properties. I also don’t have problems launching Office apps via the Start Search prompt. I do this every day. And you are right, Vista is slower than XP. This is how it should be with an advanced operating system.

    Ochiru, Start++ is certainly great, too. I reviewed it a while back. However, I think Vista’s Start Search prompt is good enough for the average end user. As to running Windows Server 2008 as a workstation, I’ve read several articles about this topic and some say it is a myth that Server2008 is faster than Vista SP1. After all, they have the same code base. Thus if you configured them the same way and if you have the same services running, you probably won’t experience a speed difference. But Hyper-V is indeed a argument for Server 2008.

Leave a reply

Please enclose code in pre tags

Your email address will not be published.


© 4sysops 2006 - 2023


Please ask IT administration questions in the forums. Any other messages are welcome.


Log in with your credentials


Forgot your details?

Create Account