Latest posts by Wolfgang Sommergut (see all)
- Migrate a WSUS database from WID to SQL Server - Mon, Jan 13 2020
- Audit changes in the Windows registry - Wed, Jan 8 2020
- Move WSUS database and content (updates) to a different drive or folder - Wed, Dec 11 2019
Microsoft has already implemented the concept of an isolated application environment with Application Guard, but it only works for the web browser. Sandbox is a generic form of Application Guard without its specific browser-related functions such as the persistent saving of bookmarks and downloads.
No Hyper-V installation required ^
A VM runs under the hood of the Sandbox. As with the other VBS features, users do not have to install Hyper-V or provide their own images for the guest operating system. All of this happens automatically in the background and is thus transparent to the user.
For this purpose, the Sandbox does not bring a virtual disk with a full Windows 10, but it simply shares the binaries of the host OS (therefore, its VM mostly contains links to the required files of the host).
It shares DLLs with the host not only on disk but also in memory. In this respect, the Sandbox more closely resembles a container and is less isolated from the host OS than a conventional VM.
No access to the local network ^
While normal VMs under a client Hyper-V have relatively tight integration with the host by allowing users to copy files or access network drives, the Sandbox largely isolates its content from the environment. Each time you launch a new copy, you'll get a clean install of Windows 10, and it discards any changes to the OS upon shutdown.
This prevents access to file shares and sharing directories in the Sandbox. The data exchange between guest and host is only possible via copy and paste. As with all remote desktop connections, you can also copy files via Remote Desktop Protocol (RDP) in this way.
Update: Starting with build 18342 of Windows 10 the sandbox can be configured using an XML file with the extension .wsb. This way you cannot only de/activate vGPUs, but it also lets you loosen some of the default restrictions.
For example you can allow or deny access to the network. In addition, directories on the host may be shared for exchanging data (even with write permission). The new option to automatically run a startup script comes in handy if you want to install or copy applications from a file share.
The settings and the syntax of the configuration file is documented in this post on Microsoft TechCommunity.
IT pros as a target group ^
This characteristic raises the question for which scenarios and users the Sandbox is suitable. Launching Sandbox in the current preview requires administrative rights. Hence it is not possible for standard users not allowed to install software on their PCs to run it in this isolated environment either.
From a usability point of view, working in a desktop on a desktop is likely to be very confusing for technically less experienced users.
Since the most important application for a closed environment for non-technical users is the web browser, Application Guard is the better option. This allows Microsoft Edge to run seamlessly on the Windows desktop.
An obvious application for Sandbox would be an admin workstation. Based on the privileged administrative workstation (PAW) concept, Microsoft strongly recommends separating environments where management tools run with elevated privileges from those used for everyday work (such as web browsing).
Using the Sandbox, the system administrator could easily implement this best practice by executing administrative tasks in the host system and transferring other activities to the isolated environment.
Advantages of the Sandbox ^
Compared to a normal VM, the Sandbox has several advantages on a PAW:
- There's no need to set up a VM or install an OS in it.
- Code sharing with the host means its resource consumption is moderate.
- No patch management is required because it shares the binaries with the host OS.
- It discards all user data including malware after exiting. In a normal VM with a longer lifespan, malware could survive.
- The Sandbox does not grant access to resources in the local network and thus prevents the spread of malware.
It is obvious the Sandbox is primarily suitable for activities for which onboard tools such as the Edge browser are sufficient. You can also quickly deploy portable applications by transferring them to the Sandbox via copy and paste. However, installing large software packages is a waste of time because you'll lose them upon closing the Sandbox.
Therefore this behavior makes it viable for testing unknown software. Programs run in the context of a local Sandbox user (WDAGUtilityAccount). There's no support for installations that require a system reboot or store apps.
Installation and system requirements ^
Windows Sandbox is on board as an optional feature you can add to the system using the Control Panel. It is currently missing from the Settings app generally used to manage such additional modules.
Since the feature is based on Hyper-V, it has similar hardware requirements as the hypervisor. These include the virtualization extensions of the processor (with at least two cores) and 8 GB RAM for it to work smoothly.
If you want to try out the Windows Sandbox in a VM, you have to activate nested virtualization (in the VMware Workstation, you virtualize Intel-VT or AMD-V as well as the Performance Counters).
This feature is only available for Windows 10 Pro and Windows 10 Enterprise starting with build 18305.