Windows 8 was the first Windows version to give us these “immersive,” full-screen apps that have gone through so many name changes I simply can’t keep them straight. Remember “Metro” apps? How about “Modern” apps? How about “Windows 8” apps?
My understanding is that Microsoft terms these special apps “Windows Store” apps, which seems to be a bit of a misnomer. For instance, the default Windows 8.1 apps don’t come from the Windows Store. How about apps that you code yourself?
Default app behavior in Windows 8 and Windows 8.1 ^
I’ve been a Windows power user since version 3.1. If I had navigation trouble with Windows 8 apps, I can only imagine the trouble that ordinary end users had. To wit:
- Having to point to the upper-left corner to get a list of recent apps worked only a portion of the time, if at all.
- Right-clicking to bring up the app’s navigation system, again, works inconsistently.
- The overall lack of window chrome is disconcerting and feels like a giant waste of screen real estate.
- The app “snapping” behavior supposedly made it easier to view more than one app on-screen at a time, but the integration between Windows Store apps and traditional desktop apps was poor.
In my opinion, all of the touch-centric features of Windows Store apps worked okay on a tablet (I had a first-generation Windows Surface running Windows RT), but these were a “fish out of water” on a desktop operating system—even with touch monitors.
Windows 8.1 Update provided some minor improvements to the Windows Store app behavior. In particular, you can get to running Windows Store apps from the taskbar. Also, you do have minimal window chrome to give the user some context of what’s going on.
I’ve summarized the new Windows 8.1 Store app features in the following screenshot:
Windows Store app improvements in Windows 8.1
Although the Windows 8.1 Update app improvements are helpful, we’re still left fumbling around trying to obtain the app’s navigation structure. For instance, how do you get to the Weather app settings?
Default app behavior in Windows 10 Technical Preview ^
As I discussed in my article on the Windows 10 Technical Preview Start menu, the Start screen is disabled by default, and some default Windows Store apps are automatically tucked into the Start menu interface.
Also, the Windows Store apps run in a completely resizable window, as you can see in this screenshot:
Default Windows Store app behavior in Windows 10 Technical Preview
Microsoft obviously paid attention to customer feedback. Take a look at my annotated screenshot and ponder the changes to the interface and default app behaviors:
Windows Store app improvements in Windows 10 Technical Preview
Getting to know the new control menu ^
I’d like to close this article by introducing you to what I think is the best addition to Windows Store app behavior: the newly expanded app control menu. I doubt you’ll see this interface element in Windows RT, but it works great in Windows 10. Look at the following screenshot, which shows a “mash-up” of most control menu commands. I’ll then briefly explain them for you.
Control menu commands in Windows 10 Technical Preview
- App Commands: This invokes the app’s control surface, which was previously accessed on desktop Windows by right-clicking inside the app window.
- Search: One-click access to system-wide search is provided here, with app results placed first.
- Share: Send app data to other apps. (I use this feature on my Apple devices every day.)
- Project: This is the verb, not the noun (yeah, I made that mistake at first). Here, we can easily put our app’s content on another monitor or a portable projector.
- Settings: Set app options and also have access to system-wide settings.
From what I’ve seen, the specific content of a Windows Store app’s control menu depends upon the app in question. However, having a single, unified way to access these commands is a big win, in my humble opinion.
What happened to Charms, you may wonder? Well, in this build of Windows 10, they are (fortunately) absent. The word on the proverbial street is that charms may persist in Windows RT for tablet devices.
Thus far, I’m very happy with the changes Microsoft added to Windows 10 Technical Preview. For the past year, I’ve been running Windows 8.1 on my desktop PC, but I installed Stardock’s Start8, and I completely ignore the Start screen and Windows Store apps.
In Windows 10 Technical Preview, the Start screen is disabled by default. I can remove the live tiles from the Start menu, and I continue to be productive in the way in which I’m most comfortable.
From my limited perspective as a non-Microsoft employee, it seems to me that Microsoft may be back-pedaling a bit on their “grand, unified operating system” experiment that they began with Windows 8, Windows RT, and Windows Phone 8. It’s a neat idea, in principle, to have (largely) the same OS running on your smartphone, Xbox One, tablet, and laptop, but again I found the inclusion of touch-centric controls on a desktop box to be an almost insurmountable obstacle.
What do you think of all this? Please let us know in the comments. Thanks a lot for reading.