Tue 28 Aug 2007
It was hard to miss the news about the WGA (Windows Genuine Advantage (?)) outage Microsoft had this weekend. Just in case you managed it somehow, you might want to catch up on it in this Computerworld article. Microsoft’s Windows Genuine Advantage blog has an update about the “continuing investigation”. Alex Kochis claims that “fewer than 12,000 systems were affected”.
Considering how many (genuine) Windows systems are out there, this doesn’t seem to be so much. However, 12,000 paying customers ran into problems even though Microsoft promised them that WGA will give them a “genuine advantage”.
System failures always happen. No IT system has a 100% up time. What is annoying about WGA is that Microsoft tells their customers it is only to their advantage. This is comparable to the new activation rules for Vista and Windows Server 2008. They unquestionably cause extra costs for Windows customers. But Microsoft keeps telling us that it is only for our best interest. I never understood why should higher revenues for Microsoft benefit me.
This incident is just another example that shows that any kind of anti-piracy technology only brings disadvantage to the customer. Microsoft knows that, and we know it, too. It is this obvious insincerity that displeases me.
Update: The WGA Blog has now an explanation of the incident.


Newsletter: 


These are just typical marketing guys spurting complete nonsense. But that’s how the world works (but you already knew that).
WAR IS PEACE; FREEDOM IS SLAVERY; IGNORANCE IS STRENGTH; WGA IS AN ADVANTAGE
I wonder if it really works. I guess I am not the only one who is repelled by this kind of marketing. But maybe this is just where we differ from the Americans. I think they are much more relaxed about things like this.
If you think that the DRM activation issues that users face with WGA, OGA and DRM under Vista are a concern, wait until every other software vendor (ISVs) starts coming up with varied combinations and derivatives on how they will “activate/control” your PC.
From October ISVs will be able to license, using similar techniques to WGA/OGA/DRM using Software Licensing and Protection Services (SLP Services).
see http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/features/2007/jul07/07-10slpservices.mspx
When this happens it will be a disaster beyond proportions unspeakable as the ISVs come up with their own “innovative ways” to turn on/off software to control licensing usage!
Whilst it might be true that Microsoft is tracking your PID via a software manifest with encrypted hardware details, I’d rather trust Microsoft to do that safely than a small time software developer who has weak systems control and leaves backdoors open for attack, just so they can activate/track their own ISV licenses using DRM.
Microsoft needs to be given, by business houses, the very clear message (I am not saying jump to Open Source either by making this statement) that the software once licensed correctly and installed needs to be left stable and alone so that we can run the business without interference and without further activation/reactivation/validation. ie; activate once then go away and let us run the business under our control !
Letting the SLP source code out to ISVs is a huge risk that we all need to be very wary of and stamp out as vocally as we can!